Margarita N. Lavides

How Threatened are Philippine Marine Fishes: Setting Conservation Baselines for Exploited Species

Photo taken while doing fieldwork in Balicasag island during an early morning fish catch monitoring at a landing site in Balicasag with me holding an Epinephelus grouper caught by a fisher by hook and line after close to three hours of fishing.

Town/RegionCountryCategoriesDate
Balicasag Island
Pamilacan Island
PhilippinesAsia, Fish, Marine7 Feb 2007

The Philippines which lies in the epicentre (Carpenter & Springer 2005) and in the world’s most threatened region of marine biodiversity (Roberts et al. 2002), is probably losing marine fish species, yet we know almost nothing about it. Philippine marine fisheries landings are declining (Alcala & Russ 2002; Barut et al. 2004) but the trajectories of vulnerable species are rarely understood. Even the recent history of exploitation is poorly studied in most areas, and the baselines from which current depletions have descended are uncertain, meaning the targets for recovery objectives, where these might be addressed in the future are uncertain. Each human generation varies in its perception of a fishery and the perceptions which are essential for management have scarcely been studied in this region with its fast-growing human population.

Degradation of 70% of the Philippine coral reefs, overfishing and human population growth (Barut 2004) led to an annual reef fish production of 350,000 tonnes declining to about 177,500 tonnes by1990s (Alcala & Russ 2002). This study will give substance to the abundance trends in different groups and species of Philippine marine fishes using the multiple data sources. Information collected from several generations of fishermen creates a series of historical windows into a fishery’s local ecology that can be used to identify long term processes in the fishery (Ames 2001). Compiling an historical database such as those from fish collection records and from people’s perceptions forms a timeline that allows those processes to be studied. These will provide valuable inputs to the development of conservation and management plans and policies in the marine conservation and fisheries sector of the country.

In particular, this project will provide inputs to setting conservation priorities for exploited species or it will provide inputs to fisheries management of particular fishing grounds of the Philippines, e.g. Leyte Gulf At the very least, the project will substantiate the abundance trends of at least 20 marine fish species included in the top 30 species of Philippine fisheries. Since the work will be done in collaboration with the national Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources (BFAR) through the National Fisheries Research and Development Institute (NFRDI), the Philippine National Museum and the Coastal Conservation and Education Foundation with whom letters of agreement have already been exchanged and face-to-face meetings in the scoping study done, the output of this project will be readily taken up by relevant end users.

For more information contact Margarita.Lavides@ncl.ac.uk or go to http://www.ncl.ac.uk/fish

Project Update: July 2007

An initial analysis was done on 17-22 year data of 50 marine fish stocks from Davao Gulf, Leyte Gulf and Camotes Sea using comparative phylogenetic analysis. Regression analysis shows that there is a significant negative relationship between catch per unit effort (CPUE) and the life history maximum size at P = 0.003.

A fieldwork was recently completed in Pamilacan island and Balicasag island, both in Bohol, to cover human perception by fishers' interviews and focus group discussions. A total of 252 interviews and three focus group discussions were conducted in Pamilacan island while a total of 152 interviews and two focus group discussions were conducted in Balicasag island. Initial readings from the raw data reveal a declining reef fisheries trend since the 1980s in Pamilacan while a sustained reef fisheries since the 1980s, and possibly since the 1950s is indicated by the raw data of Balicasag island. Currently, a database is being constructed using Access for these datasets and following this is the statistical analysis using mixed modelling.

Project Update: September 2008

Little is known about long term trends in fish abundance in the most biodiverse marine ecosystem (coral reef) in one of the most marine biodiverse regions (the Philippines). I analysed finfish family level catch per unit effort (CPUE) data for 1950-2007 from hook-and-line and gillnet based on fishers' knowledge and underwater visual census (UVC)numerical abundance data for 1985-2007 from Pamilacan and Balicasag islands; and CPUE species level landings data for 1983-2005 from Davao Gulf and the Camotes Sea. Linear mixed models with random intercept and generalised least squares showed that in CPUE data large predators (e.g. Epinephelinae, Lutjanidae, Carangidae and Lethrinidae)declined the most while in UVC abundances other common target families (e.g. Acanthuridae, Caesionidae and Scaridae) declined the most.

Declines in UVC data of large predators (e.g. Epinephelinae, Carangidae and Lethrinidae) were not detected, possibly because these groups were depleted prior to the period as shown by mean abundances of 0-<1 per 500m2 in non-sanctuary areas from 1985 to 2007 at Pamilacan. Non-target families such as Pomacanthidae, Chaetodontidae and Zanclidae declined in abundance. Several grouper species, considered very vulnerable reef apex predators, declined in mean size over the study period based on fishers' knowledge. There was positive correlation between the most reduced in size and either the largest grouper species or the species with the lowest intrinsic rate of increase. At least 18 species no longer caught based on fisher interviews and species disappearances from UVC data (1999-2007) were moderate to very large-bodied and some slow-growing and late-maturing fish, concurring with the Fishbase vulnerability index categories of 'moderate' to 'very high'. At Davao and Camotes almost half of the major target species declined due to fishing pressure. Declines for Pamilacan and Balicasag are attributed to intrinsic vulnerability and fishing pressure in conjunction with habitat degradation. The significance of these findings at local, national and global levels are discussed.

Final Report

Read about the activities undertaken and findings of this project in the final report below.

File DownloadSize
Final Report.doc704 KB

Other Projects in: